That would be too severe of medicine; I would only like to fall back on that in desperation.
- HaroldFinch
Post a reply
Before posting, please read how to report bug or request support effectively.
Bug reports without an attached log file are usually useless.
Topic review
- martin
Sure.
Meanwhile, you can disable symlink-resolution site-wide:
https://winscp.net/eng/docs/ui_login_directories
Meanwhile, you can disable symlink-resolution site-wide:
https://winscp.net/eng/docs/ui_login_directories
- HaroldFinch
While waiting for OpenSSH to get their act together and support more modern protocols, would a temp hack fix for WinSCP be to add an option to not follow sym links in the Find Files dialog box?
- martin
Yes, SFTP version 4 fixes this.
Problem is that OpenSSH server supports only version 3.
Problem is that OpenSSH server supports only version 3.
- HaroldFinch
Martin: thanks for figuring this out.
Does SFTP protocol version 4+ fix this issue?
My server which has this problem is running CentOS 6.4, which is not exactly bleeding edge anymore. Perhaps if it was updated, or somehow just the SFTP portion was, then this could be cured?
Does SFTP protocol version 4+ fix this issue?
My server which has this problem is running CentOS 6.4, which is not exactly bleeding edge anymore. Perhaps if it was updated, or somehow just the SFTP portion was, then this could be cured?
- martin
Thanks for the log. The problem is that there's symlink pointing to a symlink. With limitation of SFTP protocol version 3 (as implemented by OpenSSH), WinSCP won't find out that the second symlink is a symlink, so it won't detect the loop. It can definitely be worked around, but it's quite a change. So I'll see what the demand is.
- HaroldFinch
Martin: I ran the same search with your new debug build last night for much longer, and am sure that it hit the symlink this time.
I am attaching the resulting WinSCP16A8trace.log file as a private file for you.
I am attaching the resulting WinSCP16A8trace.log file as a private file for you.
- martin
@smitty123: I have sent you an email with a debug version of WinSCP to address you have used to register on this forum.
- martin
@HaroldFinch: I have sent you new debug version. Let it run longer. It didn't even get to the symlink before you stopped it.
- smitty123
i noticed that too in relation to symbolic (?) links on my nas. it just keeps appending the link to the searched path and round it goes in a loop.
Also i'd like it if we could do things with the files found in the results. there's not much we can do but it would be more usefull if we could right-click them individually or as a lot and do file commands like delete, move, open folder etc.
Also i'd like it if we could do things with the files found in the results. there's not much we can do but it would be more usefull if we could right-click them individually or as a lot and do file commands like delete, move, open folder etc.
- HaroldFinch
Martin, here is what I did:
(Above formatted as code because that is the only way I can see to preserve line indents)
I am attaching the resulting WinSCP16A8trace.log file as a private file for you.
--I downloaded the debug build from the link that you emailed me
--I extracted everything from its zip file
--I noticed that the extraction produced a WinSCP.exe direct executable file (i.e. the full program, NOT an installer)
--so, I double clicked on that WinSCP.exe file; all subsequent operations below were done with it
--NOTE: I did NOT uninstall my normal WinSCP install (5.5.6)
--I had already rebooted my machine last night, after the last time I used the 5.5.6 GUI
--I did not start up th 5.5.6 GUI so far today
--I opened Task Manager and looked under processes, and verified that no instance of 5.5.6 was running
--that debug WinSCP.exe instance was agonizingly slow!
--maybe 1000X slower than the normal build
--operations that should be < 1 sec can take > 1 minute...
--fortunately, the debug WinSCP.exe instance did pick up old settings, so login to my server was easy
--I redid the same exact Find File operation as described in my original post
--after several minutes, I clicked on the stop button to kill the search, and then I shut down the program
--NOTE: this time, when the search was going on, I did not see the path endlessly repeat at the bottom of the Find File dialog
(Above formatted as code because that is the only way I can see to preserve line indents)
I am attaching the resulting WinSCP16A8trace.log file as a private file for you.
- martin
Thanks for the log.
I have sent you an email with a debug version of WinSCP to address you have used to register on this forum.
I have sent you an email with a debug version of WinSCP to address you have used to register on this forum.
- HaroldFinch
Martin,
As per your suggestion, I first temporarily enabled session logging to the file WinSCP.log, which is attached here.
I then did the same search as before (looking for a file of type
Once again, from the paths shown on the bottom of the Find dialog, it seemed to be stuck in a loop.
So, after several seconds, I manually stopped the Find.
I hope that the log helps you track down the problem. Looking over it, the logs seem to repeat, which seems to confirm my guess that that the code got stuck in a loop.
As per your suggestion, I first temporarily enabled session logging to the file WinSCP.log, which is attached here.
I then did the same search as before (looking for a file of type
*22559* in my /sys directory).
Once again, from the paths shown on the bottom of the Find dialog, it seemed to be stuck in a loop.
So, after several seconds, I manually stopped the Find.
I hope that the log helps you track down the problem. Looking over it, the logs seem to repeat, which seems to confirm my guess that that the code got stuck in a loop.
- martin
Re: Find Files gets stuck in endless loop (Bug 1093 not fixed?)
Please attach a full log file showing the problem (using the latest version of WinSCP).
To generate log file, enable logging, log in to your server and do the operation and only the operation that causes the error. Submit the log with your post as an attachment. Note that passwords and passphrases not stored in the log. You may want to remove other data you consider sensitive though, such as host names, IP addresses, account names or file names (unless they are relevant to the problem). If you do not want to post the log publicly, you can mark the attachment as private.
- HaroldFinch
Find Files gets stuck in endless loop (Bug 1093 not fixed?)
I tried using the Find Dialog today, and it got stuck in an endless loop.
The
In particular, look at how the path on the bottom seems to be repeating. Looks to me like it has gotten stuck in an infinite loop that involves
On my file system,
So, my guess is that this infinite loop is due to following a link. In other words, bug 1093 appears to still be present in current stable builds of WinSCP.
I was using WinSCP 5.5.1, but tried upgrading to the latest stable release, 5.5.6 as of today, and I still see this bug.
I am running on Win 7 Pro 64 bit (tho this likely makes no difference).
The connection protocol is SFTP.
I am using the GUI.
No error dialog ever appears--the GUI spins endlessly in the Find Dialog.
Personal note to the WinSCP devs: thanks so much for this program--it has made my life much easier!
The
WinSCP_find_bug.png file that I attached to this post shows what the Find Dialog looks like when it gets stuck.
In particular, look at how the path on the bottom seems to be repeating. Looks to me like it has gotten stuck in an infinite loop that involves
/sys/devices/platform/pcspkr/subsystem.
On my file system,
/sys/devices/platform/pcspkr/subsystem is a link that points to ../../../bus/platform.
So, my guess is that this infinite loop is due to following a link. In other words, bug 1093 appears to still be present in current stable builds of WinSCP.
I was using WinSCP 5.5.1, but tried upgrading to the latest stable release, 5.5.6 as of today, and I still see this bug.
I am running on Win 7 Pro 64 bit (tho this likely makes no difference).
The connection protocol is SFTP.
I am using the GUI.
No error dialog ever appears--the GUI spins endlessly in the Find Dialog.
Personal note to the WinSCP devs: thanks so much for this program--it has made my life much easier!